StockSetups vs Trade Ideas
AI-backtested day-trading signals via the Holly engine.
Trade Ideas is a veteran scanning platform best known for Holly, its AI that backtests strategies overnight and surfaces live intraday signals the next session. To its real credit, Trade Ideas publishes a live trade log — losers included — which is one of the most honest track records in the category.
It's built for active day traders and runs roughly $127–254/mo (approx., as of mid-2026), Windows-first, with no real free trial and an all-sales-final policy. StockSetups takes a different shape: a $29 all-in plan that fuses the nightly scan, real-time alerts, AI ranking and alt-data into one per-symbol dossier, with a 14-day free trial and one-click cancel.
Side by side
| Trade Ideas | StockSetups | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | ≈ $127–254/mo (approx., mid-2026) | $29/mo flat — less on annual |
| Trial & billing | No real trial; all sales final (crippled free 'Par' plan) | 14-day free trial, cancel in one click, free board forever |
| Daily pattern scan | Real-time scanning + Holly AI signals (day-trading focus) | ~12,300 US stocks & ETFs → 4 long lanes, conviction + trade plan |
| Real-time alerts | Real-time alerts — a core strength | 35+ intraday alert types — included, no add-on |
| AI ranking & 'why it's moving' | Holly AI backtested signals (deeper AI on Premium) | AI Smart Picks (Claude Opus) + AI catalyst — included |
| Congress / insider / Reddit / SEC | Not a focus — scanning/AI, not a fused alt-data dossier | All fused into one per-symbol dossier (incl. executive OGE) |
| Public track record | Publishes a live trade log incl. losers (the benchmark) | Forward-tracked Signal Report Card, win/loss shown |
| Charting | Functional; multi-window UI often called dated | Purpose-built setup charts (not a full TradingView-style studio) |
| Options flow | Not a focus | Not offered |
| Mobile app | Windows-first desktop | Web only — native app not yet |
Trade Ideas pricing and features are approximate and were last verified June 26, 2026 — check their site for current details.
Choose Trade Ideas if…
- You're an active day trader who wants an AI engine firing live intraday signals.
- You value Holly's overnight backtesting and a long, public live-results log.
- You're on Windows and live in a multi-window day-trading cockpit.
Choose StockSetups if…
- You want one flat $29 plan instead of $127–254/mo with AI gated to the top tier.
- You want pattern setups fused with fundamentals, congress/insider, Reddit, SEC filings and an AI catalyst per symbol — not just signals.
- You want a real free trial and to keep a genuinely useful free board.
Frequently asked
Is StockSetups a Trade Ideas alternative?
For swing and setup-focused traders, yes — it covers daily pattern scanning, real-time alerts and AI ranking in one $29 plan. Trade Ideas remains stronger for pure intraday AI signal generation via Holly.
Get daily signals & real-time alerts.
StockSetups scans ~12,300 US stocks & ETFs after every close and sorts every long setup into four ranked lanes — each with a trade plan — plus an always-on engine firing 35+ real-time intraday alerts. Free for 14 days, cancel in one click.
Start free — 14-day full access →More comparisons
Accuracy note. Competitor names and logos are the property of their respective owners; StockSetups is not affiliated with Trade Ideas. The pricing, features and other details above were accurate to the best of our knowledge as of June 26, 2026, and competitor offerings change often. This comparison is our opinion, provided for general information only — always confirm current details on Trade Ideas's own site. Spot something out of date or wrong? Please contact us and we'll fix it.